Baked Vanilla Custard with Nutmeg

Baked Custard is coming, but first … it’s Friday, and I won an award! 

Jenn at Bread + Butter passed along the Premio Meme Award to me!  Thank you Jenn!

Along with this award I am supposed to tell you all seven things about my personality, and then pass the award to seven other bloggers.  So, if you are interested, the seven things are posted after the recipe.

I am passing this award on to the following AWESOME food bloggers who I count among my blogging friends.  Not only are they kind and supportive, they really seem to care.  That is so rare these days!

Maria at Two Peas and Their Pod
Don at Foodie Prints
Deeba at Passionate About Baking
Marye Audet at Baking Delights
Donna at Way More Homemade
Alta at Tasty Treats at Home
Clara at I Heart Cuppycakes

Now, it’s time for dessert!


If you have ever eaten at a Luby’s Cafeteria then you will completely understand what I am about to say. 

When I was a child I lived in San Antonio, Texas.  On most Sunday’s my family would eat lunch at the Luby’s Cafeteria after church.  It was always busy, a favorite with the over 60 set to be sure, and I always made a big production of not wanting to wait in line.  You see, you have to stand in line like any cafeteria, all the while seeing the wonderful food in the shiny steel steam tables.  


As you wait you smell the smells, you see the happy people with full trays loaded with their meal wander into the dining room to find a seat, and when you are a child you HATE it.  It was sheer torture to the 6, 7, and 8 year old I was and I made sure my whole family knew how I suffered.

Despite the torture, and my protests, I loved Luby’s!  I almost always got the same thing every visit.  I got the fried fish platter with tartar sauce, green beans, macaroni and cheese, clover leaf roll, and chocolate ice box pie for dessert. 

I say I almost always got the same thing because there were two deviations from my most favorite meal.  One was the cheese enchiladas, which they did not always have on the menu, and the other was the egg custard.


I always had a hard time when it came to desserts.  Seeing them sitting there on their frosty metal tray caused the kind of anxiety only the sugar obsessed can know.  Chocolate is my first love, and I was hard pressed to choose another against it.  I did stray into the fruit pies, the cakes were tempting, but for the most part I had ice box pie or the egg custard.  In its unassuming cup it was my creamy runner-up.   It had a sprinkle of spice on the top which, when combined with the vanilla in the custard, was pure custard heaven! 

Now that I know my way around a kitchen I am able to recreate this custard at home, and that is what I present to you now. 

Baked Vanilla Custard with Nutmeg   Yield 4

2 whole eggs
1 egg yolk
1/4 cup sugar
2 cups milk
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Nutmeg, freshly grated


Heat the oven to 325 F and in a kettle boil four cups of water.

 DSCF2200 DSCF2203

In a large bowl whisk the eggs, egg yolk, vanilla, and sugar until well combined.


In a sauce pan heat the milk until it simmers. Remove from the heat. 


Using a ladle add the hot milk to the egg mixture, one ladle at a time while constantly whisking, until half the mixture is added, then add the remaining milk and blend well. 

DSCF2206 DSCF2207 DSCF2208 

Strain the mixture into a bowl or jug with a pour spout.   Pour the custard into four 6oz ramekins placed inside a deep roasting pan.  Dust the tops with fresh nutmeg.  

DSCF2209 DSCF2218 

Place the roasting pan on the middle rack of the oven and carefully add the boiling water, making sure it reaches 3/4 of the way up the ramekins.  Bake for 40 minutes, or until the custard is set at the edges but jiggly in the center.


Remove from the oven and allow to cool in the water bath for 30 minutes, then remove the cups from the pan and cool to room temp.  Chill for four hours in the fridge before serving.



Ok, as promised here are the seven things about me!  Prepare to be bored whit-less!

1. Picky – I am really picky.  Be it food, work, or driving, I am a really picky person about the oddest things.  For example, I detest fresh tomato and can’t stand even a single seed on my food.  I just hate the flavor.  I also like all my cookbooks to be lined up a certain way. 

2. Goofy – Buried deep within the heart of this *mumble*-one year old is the heart of a five year old.  Ok. She’s four.  I love cartoons, I adore being pushed on the swings, and I love to try on hats at the department store just to get odd reactions from other shoppers. 

3. Private – I am a VERY private person.  Most people where I work do not know a whole lot about me other than what I tell them, and many of you know that much from reading my blog.  I think it comes from a fear of rejection.  Or. maybe the details of my life are just depressingly dull.  Hummm.

4. Loyal – I am a very loyal person once you get to know me.  If I think someone has slighted you, said something ugly about/to you, or been generally nasty not only will I call them out on it, I will then remove them from my life forever.  Friendship is something very rare for me and I protect my friends like a mama bear protects her cubs.

5. Insecure – I am an insecure person.  Yes, I know it takes some amount of security to admit it, but I am.  I always worry that what I do is not enough.  I never want anyone to think that I did not do my part, or that I did not care enough to do my best.

6.  Quick Temper – This one is a really bad one, but it is honest.  I get mad really easily.  I think it comes from being an Aries.  Lucky for those around me my temper is quick to fizzle.  I never really stay mad for long, unless it is something really terrible, then my mad becomes a stubborn grudge.

7. Sentimental – I have lots of fond memories from growing up, and I love to discover something that triggers nostalgia.  Be it food, a smell, driving through an old neighborhood, or going through a box of old high school awards, I love to remember the good times.

© 2009, Evil Shenanigans. All rights reserved.

Author: Kelly

Share This Post On
  • Awww..thanks.. I will try to get to it later..and the custard sounds …Yum!

  • Thanks, I’m honored that you passed the award on to me! And your vanilla custard looks delish! 🙂 I’ll have to try, I love custards. Hmm, now what will my 7 things be?

  • Kelly

    The seven things was the hardest part! *sigh* I feel so exposed! 😉

  • You are awesome & hope u know it! I am everythign your meme says you are, except insecure, & now am very humbled too! Do you know you are ‘egging’ an eggophobic to make this custard? xoxoxo, THANK YOU (courtesy)

  • Congratulations to all the awardees! Looks like a lovely custard too. Best, s

  • You decerve this award. It’s great to know you a little better. Makes your cooking and baking shine through even more.

    Custard = yummy deliciousness.

  • Darn…it’s “deserve”. where’s that edit button. lol.

  • The custard sounds delicious. So close to one of our faves…the crème brulée. The hint of nutmeg is nice!

  • Thanks for the recipe, Kelly, and thanks for allowing us to get to know you better too. I value loyalty, because I think it’s so rare. Your friends should be grateful to have a fiercely loyal friend like you.

    I LOVE Luby’s!! I even have their cookbook which I picked up from a garage sale a few years ago. My favorite is the green jello cottage cheese pineapple salad thingy on a bed of wilted lettuce that they put at the beginning of the serving line and the grilled chopped steak. (Drool …)

  • That custard looks so creamy. I’ve saved this to my recipe box and I will definitely try this soon!

  • I could just dive onto the computer screen for a spoonful of that! It looks so delicious.

  • Your custard looks lovely. Another one for my to-do list. Thanks.

  • Looks cool almost a cross between a flan and cremme milk, well done looks great. 🙂 xx Rico-Recipe

  • I love custards and never made them until this year. Yours sounds wonderful.

  • I have a vanilla bean in my cupboard that may just have to make it’s way into this custard. Yum!

  • Loved this post. When I was younger we used to hit up Luby’s when we would travel to Tennessee so I can picture your experience perfectly! Your custard looks wonderful.

  • It looks simply yummy…and so simple to make. I am definitely going to try this recipe. Thank You so much for sharing.

  • Pingback: Recipe Round-Up ~ May 2-8 Sugared Ellipses . . .()

  • Vanilla custard sounds so simple and yet it is so addictively good!

  • CB

    I am SO behind on saying THANK YOU for the award. Please forgive my tardiness. I squeal for blog awards. *SQUEAL* It’s actually kinda of embarrassing. Sshhh… don’t tell anyone, k?
    Clara @ iheartcuppycakes!

  • Jen

    I just made these custards last night and they were amazing! I had one for breakfast this morning 🙂 I just started my blog, and I was wondering if you would mind if I posted about your recipe on the blog, giving you the credit of course. Feel free to check out the blog.

  • Pingback: Goose Egg Vanilla Custard « The Left Over Queen()

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This